News Flash
  • Non- Joining of the candidates selected for the post of Inspector (CGST, PO & Examiner) and Tax Assistant selected through SSC CGLE- 2017- reg.Click here
  • Allocation of Inspector (CGST, Po & Examiner) and TA recommended for appointment by SSC on the basis of result of Combined Graduate Level Examination, 2018- reg.Click here ANNEXURE I || ANNEXURE II || ANNEXURE III
  • Online training on “Sevottam, Citizen’s Charter” on 28th September 2021 from 10:30 AM to 01:15 PM -reg.Click here
  • Online training on “Supply of Goods and Services” on 21st September 2021 from 10:30 AM to 01:15 PM -reg.Click here
  • Online training on “Government e-Marketing (GeM) and e-Procurement” on 16th September, 2021 from 10:30 AM to 01:15 PM -reg.Click here
  • Clarification regarding extension of time limit to apply for revocation of cancellation of registration issuedClick here
  • Notice inviting tender for hiring of office premises at Bhopal for NACIN ZC, Bhopal-reg.Click here
  • Letter issued by Director General(HRD) regarding 'Swachhta@CBIC' tabClick here
  • FINAL ALERT (ALL CCAs)-Non- Joining Status of the candidates selected through SSC CGLE 2017- reg.Click here
  • Prospective Training Report for the month September, 2021-regClick here
  • Prospective Training Report for the month September, 2021-regClick here
  • Notice dated 26.08.2021 for Customs Brokers Licensing Regulation Examination-2022Click here Hindi
  • Presidential Award of Appreciation Certificates & Medals to be announced on the occasion of Republic Day, 2022: reg.Click here Annexure
  • Notification issued to for waiver of penalty payable for noncompliance of the provisions of notification No.14/2020 – Central Tax till 30.09.2021 Click here
View All

Unjust-Enrichment

ECS subject-wise list of Central Excise cases

S No

Citation

Name of the Party

Subject Heading

1

2012 (2) ECS (71) (Tri-Del)(154KB)

M/s JSB Aluminum

The excise duty as well as education cess and S&H Education Cess paid by the appellant at the time of removal of excisable goods from his unit has been passed on the customers, therefore, any refund of the excise duty or education cess given to the appellant would amount to unjust enrichment, which is not permissible, in view of Section 11B of the Central Excise Act which provides that refund in term of the provision shall be allowed if the incidence of duty paid erroneously has not been passed on to any other person

2

2013 (2) ECS (80) (Tri-Del)(157KB)

M/s Kisan Sahkari Chini Mill Ltd.]

In view of the non-obstante clause of sub-section (3) of Section 11(B), all the refund claims made during the period w.e.f 20.09.1991 would be subject to the principle of unjust enrichment. We find that the same view has been taken by the Apex Court in the decision of Sahkari Khand Udyog Vs. CCE reported in 2005 (181) ELT 328 (SC).

3

2013(1) ECS (76) (Tri-Mad)(152KB)

M/s KONE Elevator India Pvt. Ltd

Uniformity of price cannot be bar for unjust enrichment. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai-II Vs. Allied Photographics India Ltd. Vs CCE, reported in 2004 (166) E.L.T 3 (S.C.) held that consistency of price of final goods of the assessee did not materially lead to the conclusion that incidence of duty had not passed on to the customers

4

2013 (2) ECS ( 60) (Tri-Del)(183KB)

M/s Suncity Threads Ltd

Appellant has not been able to discharge the onus placed upon it for proving that excise duty has not been recovered from their customers, though learned advocate has drawn our attention to a letter written to their jurisdictional Central Excise authorities indicating that they would not be collecting this amount from their customers.

5

2013 (2) ECS ( 66) (Tri-Del)(101KB)

M/s Chhata Sugar Co. Ltd

Unjust enrichment is applicable in rebate claims, as held by Trubunal in order dated 26.09.12 in case of KisanSahkariChini Mills- Appeal filed by party rejected

6

2013 (1) ECS (110) (Tri-Mum)(161KB)

Praj Agro Vision Ltd

It is well settled principle of interpretation of statute that a statute has to be construed without adding any words to it or subtracting any words from it and an interpretation which makes a part of the statute redundant has to be avoided