|
|
List of Court Cases CAT, Bombay Bench, Mumbai | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | Gist of Prayer | | 1. | Shri Avinash Ramraj Tripathi, Driver
F.No.32022/18/2014-Ad.III.A | W.P No.2507/2013 (OS in Bombay High Court against Order dated 05.07.2012 of CAT, Mumbai in OA No.186/2009) | For grant of Seniority & Other Benefits in the grade of UDC | Vide Boards letter F.No.A.32022/18/2014-Ad.III.A dated 13/02/2015, Commissioner of Customs (General), Mumbai has been asked to examine the matter and furnish the action taken report in the matter which is still awaited. | | 2. | Shri K.S.Toraskar
F.No. 32022/34/2015-Ad.III.A | OA No.193/2015, Mumbai | Grant of promotion to the grade of Examiner | OA No. 193/2015 filed by Smt. K.S. Toraskar and Ors before the Honble CAT, Mumbai Bench | | 3. | Shri B.B.More
F.No. 32022/37/2015-Ad.III.A | OA No.727/2015, Mumbai | Promotion of Sepoy to the Grade of LDC | OA No. 727/2014 with MP 848/2014 & 19/2015 filed by Shri B.B.More and 5 Ors before the Honble CAT, Bombay Bench, Mumbai | | 4. | Shri S.K.Sharma
F.No.32011/43/2015-Ad.III.A | OA No.259/2015, Mumbai | Implementation of N.R.Parmar Judgment | Original Application No.259/2015 No.CAT/MUM/JUDL/3288 in case of Shri S.K.Sharma & Ors V/s M/O Finance & Ors | | 5. | Central Excise Supdt Association
32022/51/2015-Ad.III.A | O.A.No.249/2015, Mumbai | Seniority List of Inspectors | OA No. 274/2015 No.CAT/MUM/JUDL filed by Central Excise Sup. Ass.Mumbai & Ors V/s M/O Finance & Ors before the Honble CAT, Bombay Bench, Mumbai | | 6. | Shri Sameer Sangra
32022/52/2015-Ad.III.A | O.A.No.224/2015, Mumbai | Implementation of N.R.Parmar Judgment | Original Application No.224/2015 No.CAT/MUM/JUDL/3167 with MP 352/2015 in case of Shri Sameer Sangra & Ors V/s M/O Finance & Ors | | 7. | Shri M.D.Kale
32022/60/2015- Ad.III.A | O.A.No.277/2015, Mumbai | Implementation of N.R.Parmar Judgment | OA No. 277/2015 No.CAT/MUM/JUD filed by Shri M.D.Kale & Ors V/s M/O Finance & 4 Ors before the Honble CAT, Bombay Bench, Mumbai | | 8. | Central Excise Supdt Association
32022/61/2015-Ad.III.A | O.A.No.274/2015, Mumbai | Seniority List of Inspectors | OA No. 274/2015 No.CAT/MUM/JUDL filed by Central Excise Sup. Ass.Mumbai & Ors V/s M/O Finance & Ors before the Honble CAT, Bombay Bench, Mumbai | | 9. | Shri R.R.Gandhi
32022/68/2015-Ad.III.A | O.A.No.347/2015, Mumbai | Grant of Seniority in the grade of Inspector | OA No. 347/2015 No.CAT/MUM/JUDL/5378 filed by Shri R.R.Gandhi V/s M/O Finance & 3 Ors before the Honble CAT, Bombay Bench, Mumbai |
Remarks- For Cases No.2-9, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai Zone have been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time. List of Court Cases CAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | | 1. | Shri Ashutosh Gautam
F.No.32022/71/2015 | Civil Writ Petition in the High Court of Delhi filed by Shri Ashutosh Gautam | Challenging the order of CIC regarding RTI Application | | 2. | Shri Harsh Kakkar
F.No.32022/01/2015 | CP (C ) 664/2014 in OA No. 2093/2005 filed by Shri Harsh Kakkar and Ors before the Honble CAT, New Delhi | Re fixation of Seniority on the basis of N.R.Parmar Judgment. | | 3. | Shri Basant Kumar Chauhan
F.No.32022/24/2015 | Notice under Ruile 29 of the Central Administrative Rules of Practice, 1993, OA No. 324/2015 filed by Shri Basant Kumar Chauhan in the Honble CAT Principal Bench, New Delhi | Benefits of Notional pay fixation and grant of MACP benefit. | | 4. | Shri Rohit Mudgal
F.No.32022/26/2015 | Writ petition (Civil) No. 4117 of 2013 filed by Shri Rohit Mudgal before the High Court of Delhi | Inter Commissionerate Transfer | | 5. | Shri Dilip Singh shaktawat
F.No.32022/27/2015 | Implementation of order of Honble Tribunal dated 29.1.2015 in OA No. 4501 / 2014 Dilip Singh shaktawat Vs Union of India & Ors | Completion of Deputation period. | | 6. | Sh. Manoj Kumar & Ors F.No.32022/28/2015 | In the case of Sh. Manoj Kumar & Ors. V/s UOI, through Chairman, CBEC, New Delhi against illegal & arbitrary action in the case of departmental promotion to the post of LDC & proposed DPC | Non Consideration in the DPC. | | 7. | Shri Sarabjeet Singh F.No.32022/77/2015 | OA No. 2835/2015 filed by Shri Sarabjeet Singh V/s UOI before the CAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi | Promotion to the grade of Inspector. | | 8. | Shri Pradeep Kumar F.No.32022/80/2015 | OA No. 3316/2015 filed by Shri Pradeep Kumar & Ors V/s UOI before the CAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi | Promotion to the grade of Senior Tax Assistant. | | 9. | Shri N.C.Kashmira F.No.32022/02/2016 | OA No. 4561/2015 filed by Shri N.C.Kashmira & Ors V/s UOI before the CAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi | Re deployment of surplus employees as Inspectors in Central Excise, Delhi. |
Remarks- For all the above Cases, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Delhi Zone have been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time. List of Court Cases CAT, Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | | 1. | Shri Anuve Kumar
F.No.32022/46/2015 | O.A.No.060/00327/2015 in case of Shri Anuve Kumar V/s UOI & Ors. | Adverse remarks in APAR for the year 2013-14 | | 2. | Shri Asheesh Sharma
F.No.32022/49/2015 | O.A.No.060/00386/2015 in case of Shri Asheesh Sharma & Ors v/s Union of India and others before Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh | Promotion to the grade of Inspector | | 3. | Smt.Kailash Devi
F.No.32022/63/2015 | O.A.No.060/00524/2015 in case of Smt.Kailash Devi v/s Union of India and others before Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh | Request for reviewing DPC for notional seniority and pay | | 4. | Shri Biranchi Saw
F.NO.32022/75/2015 | O.A.No.060/00675/2015 in case of Shri Biranchi Saw v/s Union of India and others before Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh | DPC for promotion of STA to the grade of Inspector for the recruitment year 2013-14 and 2014-15 | | 5. | Smt. Daljeet Kaur
F.No.32022/74/2015 | O.A.No.060/00678/2015 in case of Smt. Daljeet Kaur v/s Union of India and others before Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh | Promotion to the grade of Inspector against the vacancies for physically handicapped categories | | 6. | Shri Amit Kumar
F.No.32022/50/2015 | O.A.No.061/00036/2015 in case of Shri Amit Kumar & Ors v/s Union of India and others before Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh | Request for timely action for holding DPC for promotion from STA to the grade of Inspector for the Recruitment year 2015-16 |
Remarks- For all the above Cases, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh-I has been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time. List of Court Cases CAT, Bangalore bench, Bangalore | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | | 1. | Shri Rajiv Kumar Singh
F.No.32022/58/2015 | OA No.170/00586 to 00599/2015 in case of Shri Rajiv Kumar Singh & 13 Ors | Discrepancy in Seniority List of Inspectors. | | 2. | Shri Sadanand Hadagali
F.No.32022/72/2015 | OA No.170/00894/2015 in case of Shri Sdanand Hadagali V/s UOI & 3 Ors before CAT, Bangalore Bench, Bangalore | Implementation of N.R.Parmar Judgment. | | 3. | Shri B.S.Venkatesh
F.No.32022/70/2015 | OA No.170/00880/2015 in case of Shri B.S.Venkatesh V/s UOI & 3Ors before CAT, Bangalore Bench | Non Consideration for Promotion to the grade of Superintendent due to APR not up to the mark |
Remarks- For all the above Cases, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Bengaluru Zone has been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time. List of Court Cases CAT, Madras Bench, Madras | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | | 1. | Shri S.Neethisolan
F.No.32022/98/2015 | WP No.38317 of 2015 in case of Shri S.Neethisolan v/s Union of India & 2 Ors in the High Court of Judicature at Madras | Notional Promotion in the grade of Tax Assistant and further to the grade of STA and Inspector. | | 2. | Shri S.Manikandsam@ S.Subramanian & 3 Ors F.No.32022/69/2015 | WP No.310/00999/2015 in case of Shri S.Manikandsam@ S.Subramanian & 3 Ors v/s Union of India & Ors before Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras Bench, Chennai | Revision of Seniority list of Inspectors | | 3. | Shri D.S.Anandakrishnan & 9 Ors F.No.32022/65/2015 | O.A.No.310/00938/2015 in case of Shri D.S.Anandakrishnan & 9 Ors v/s Union of India & 19 Ors before Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras Bench, Chennai | Promotion to the grade of Inspector(Examiner) | | 4. | Shri S.Thangavelu & 2 Ors
F.No.32022/59/2015 | O.A.No.310/01454/2015 in case of Shri S.Thangavelu & 2 Ors v/s Union of India and 4 others before Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras Bench, Chennai | Revised Seniority list of Inspector and consequential re fixation of Seniority in the grade of Superintendent | | 5. | Shri N.Balakrishnan & Anr F.No.32022/59/2015 | O.A.No.310/00789/2015 in case of Shri N.Balakrishnan & Anr v/s Union of India and 11 others before Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras Bench, Chennai | Promotion to the grade of Inspector(Preventive Officer) | | 6. | Sh. E.T.Muralidharan
F.No.32022/15/2015 | OA No. 310/00245 of 2015 In the case of Sh. E.T.Muralidharan in the Honble CAT, Madras Bench | Re fixation of Seniority on the basis of N.R.Parmar Judgment. | | 7. | Shri Vaddadi Kishore and 2 Others
F.No.32022/23/2015 | OA No. 310/01761/2014 filed by Shri Vaddadi Kishore and 2 Others filed before the Honble CAT Madras Bench | Re fixation of Seniority on the basis of N.R.Parmar Judgment. |
Remarks- For all the above Cases, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Chennai Zone have been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time. List of Court Cases CAT, Jaipur Bench, Jaipur | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | Gist of Prayer | | 1. | Shri Heera Lal
F.No.32022/30/2015-Ad.III.A | OA No. 291/00105 of 2015, Jaipur Bench | Regarding promotion to the grade of LDC | OA No. 291/00105 of 2015 In the case of Sh. Heera Lal & Ors in the Honble CAT, Jaipur Bench, Jaipur | | 2. | Shri Vinod Kumar Purohit
F.No. 32022/64/2014-Ad.III.A | O.A No. 291/00605/2014, Jaipur Bench | Regarding promotion to the grade of Inspector | O.A.No.291/00605/2014 filed by Shri Vinod Kumar Purohit & Ors before the Honble CAT, Jaipur Bench Jaipur |
Remarks- For all the above Cases, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur Zone have been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time vide letter F.No.A.32022/30/2015-Ad.III-A dated 20.03.2015 and F.No.32022/64/2014-Ad.III-A dated 05.12.2014 respectively. List of Court Cases CAT, Calcutta Bench, Kolkata | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | | 1. | Shri Sumana Chakraborty
F.No.32022/16/2015 | Copy of Order in OA No.350/00164 of 2015 filed by Smt Sumana Chakraborty and Others before CAT, Calcutta Bench, Kolkatta. | Promotion to the Grade of Inspector from Executive Assistant |
Remarks- For all the above Cases, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Kolkata Zone has been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time. List of Court Cases CAT, Jabalpur Bench, Jabalpur | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | | 1. | Shri Man Mohan Goswami
F.No.32022/99/2015 | OA No.200/01091/2015 in case of Shri Man Mohan Goswami V/s UOI before CAT, Jabalpur Bench, Jabalpur. | Promotion to the grade of Inspector. | | 2. | Shri Satendra Singh | OA No.201/00557/2015 in case of Shri Satendra Singh V/s UOI & Ors before CAT, Jabalpur Bench, Jabalpur. | .DPC for Promotion of Ministerial Officers to the grade of Inspector. |
Remarks- For all the above Cases, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Bhopal Zone has been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time. List of Court Cases CAT, Hyderabad Bench, Hyderabad | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | | 1. | Shri B.Appa Rao, STA & Others and Shri K.Mohan. STA
F.No.32022/83/2015 | OA No.1264/2015 and 1282/2015 filed before Honble CAT, Hyderabad Bench, Hyderabad. | Promotion to the grade of Inspector. |
Remarks- For the above Case, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Hyderabad Zone has been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time. List of Court Cases CAT, High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | | 1. | Shri Kariatukaran Valson Chandrashekar
F.No.32022/57/2015 | Caveat Application in Special Application in case of Shri Kariatukaran Valson Chandrashekar before High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad. | Caveat Application with Refernce to OA No.459/2012. |
Remarks- For the above Case, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Ahmedabad Zone has been requested to defend the case and provide the present status to the Board about further developments in the case from time to time. List of Court Cases CAT, Ernakulam Bench, | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | | 1. | Shri Joseph K.John
F.No.32022/76/2015 | Final Order in OA Nos 400/2010.505/2011, 784/2011 and 262/2012 by CAT, Ernakulam Bench | Inter Commissionerate Transfer on Spouse Ground. |
Remarks: For the above Case, Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Cochin Zone Vide letter dated 11.02.2016 has been requested to file appeal before High Court of Kerala, challenging the decision of CAT, Ernakulam Bench. Ad.III-A Section, Ministry of Finance List of Pending Court Cases where order of CAT, High Court is pending for implementation/otherwise. | S.No | Name of Petitioner & File No | O.A No. & Name of Court | Subject | Remarks | | 1. | Shri C.B.Unnikrishnan
F.No.32022/29/2013-Ad.III-A | OA No.1410/2012 in case of Shri C.B.Unnikrishnan, D.E.O Grade-D before Honble CAT, Chennai Bench. | Promotion of D.E.O Grade-D in the absence of RR's of Assistant Programmer | As per Order dated 19.03.2015 passed by Honble CAT, Madras Bench, a draft speaking Order to be issued by the Commissionerate has been sent to the Board for approval which is under examination. | | 2. | Shri A.G.Makwana
F.No.32022/88/2015-Ad.III-A | Judgment in O.A No.371/2015 filed by Shri A.G.Makwana before Honble CAT, Ahmedabad Bench, Ahmedabad. | Promotion to the Grade of Tax Assistant from the Grade of LDC. | Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Vadodara Zone has forwarded a copy of CAT, Ahmedabad Bench, Ahmedabad Order dated 18.01.2016 to the Board for clarification to implement the Order or to challenge the same in High Court which is under examination. | | 3. | Shri N.C.Veera Raghava
F.No.32022/84/2015-Ad.III-A | O.A.No.1135/2015 filed by Shri N.C.Veera Raghava, Inspector and another before the Honble Central Administrative Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, Hyderabad. | Posts of Inspectors which were upgraded to the post of Superintendents in the year 2002 whether available in the grade of Inspector. | Chief Commissioner of Customs, Hyderabad vide letter dated 17.03.2016 has been advised to defend the Caveat Petition filed by applicant before High Court of Hyderabad. | | 4. | Shri T.Sarath Chander, F.No.A.32022/04/2013-Ad.III-A | O.A.No.1381/2012 filed by Shri T.Sarath Chander, Superintendent & 3 Ors before the Honble CAT, Madras Bench, Chennai | Reservation in Promotion and revision of Seniority for the post of Preventive Officer CBEC. | Commissioner of Customs, Chennai-VIII Commissionerate has sent a copy of Order dated 17.12.2015 passed by the Honble CAT to the Board for further course of action in the matter. |
List of Court Cases(AD.III-A Section) CBEC, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue | S.No. | Case Type
Case No.
Receipt Date.
Case Year | File No.
Petitioner/
Respondents
Name & Designation | Subject/Relief Sought | Court/Bench
Name;
Advocate Name;
Next Hearing Date | Role of DoPT, if any, and name of the concerned division in DoPT | Current Status | | 1. | Case Year-2016
Receipt Date-10/02/2016 | F.No.32022/05/2016-Ad.III-A filed by Shri S.V.Archarya & 16 Ors
Respondents-
1.UOI, The Revenue Secretary, D/O Revenue, M/O Finance, CBEC
2.Chairman, CBEC.
3.Principal Chief Commissioner, CE, CCA, Mumbai Zone.
4.DOPT, Secretary. | Inter se Seniority of DR and Promotee Inspectors as per Judgment of N.R.Parmar. | CAT, Bombay Bench, Mumbai
Advocate-R.G.Walia
Next Date of hearing-28.03.2016. | Name of concerned division in DOPT-
Establishment D, DOPT | Board has requested the Concerned Commissionerate to defend the case on behalf of all official respondents in consultation with Governmenmt Standing Counsel. | | 2. | Case Year-2015
Receipt Date-29/05/2015 | F.No.32022/51/2015-Ad.III-A OA No.249/2015 No.CAT/MUM/JUDL/3628 filed by Central Excise Supdts Association & Ors
Respondents-
1.UOI, The Revenue Secretary, D/O Revenue, M/O Finance, CBEC
2.Chairman, CBEC.
3.Principal Chief Commissioner, CE, CCA, Mumbai Zone.
4.DOPT, Secretary.
5.Chairman, SSC | Seniority List of Inspectors | CAT, Bombay Bench, Mumbai
Advocate-R.G.Walia | Name of concerned division in DOPT-
Establishment D, DOPT | Board has requested the Concerned Commissionerate to defend the case on behalf of all official respondents in consultation with Governmenmt Standing Counsel. | | 3. | Case Year-2015
Receipt Date-06/07/2015 | F.No.32022/60/2015-Ad.III-A OA No.277/2015 No.CAT/MUM/JUD filed by Shri M.D.Kale & Ors
Respondents-
1. 1.UOI, The Revenue Secretary, D/O Revenue, M/O Finance, CBEC
2.Chairman, CBEC.
3.Principal Chief Commissioner, CE, CCA, Mumbai Zone.
4.DOPT, Secretary.
5.Chairman, SSC | Implementation of N.R.Parmar Judgment | CAT, Bombay Bench, Mumbai
Advocate-R.G.Walia | Name of concerned division in DOPT-
Establishment D, DOPT | Board has requested the Concerned Commissionerate to defend the case on behalf of all official respondents in consultation with Governmenmt Standing Counsel. | | 4. | Case Year-2016
Receipt Date-11/01/2016 | F.No.32022/02/2016-Ad.III-A OA No.4561/2015 filed by Shri N.C.Kashmira & Ors .
Respondents-
1.UOI, The Revenue Secretary, D/O Revenue, M/O Finance, CBEC
2.Chairman, CBEC.
3.Chief Commissioner of Central Excise, Delhi Zone (Cadre Control).
4.DOPT, Secretary | Re deployment of surplus employees as Inspectors in Central Excise, Delhi. | CAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi.
Advocate-
M.K.Bhardwaj. | Name of concerned division in DOPT-
CS-III, Lonayak Bhavan. | Board has requested the Concerned Commissionerate to defend the case on behalf of all official respondents in consultation with Governmenmt Standing Counsel |
|
