News Flash
  • Result of Customs Brokers Licensing Regulations written exam for 2022 held on 03.08.2022 Click here
  • Online training on "Advance Ruling: An Introduction" for Group 'A' officers of CBIC on 17.08.2022 from 10:30 AM to 01:15 PM -reg Click here
  • Notification issued to implement e-invoicing for the taxpayers having aggregate turnover exceeding Rs. 10 Cr from 01st October, 2022 Click here
  • Calling Options/Preferences from selected candidates for the post of Stenographer Grade I & Grade II tor allocation of Zones/Formations - regsteno- I options and Steno- II options
  • Letter dt. 29.07.2022 regarding Equal Opportunity Policy Letter and Equal Opportunity Policy
  • Draft Integrated All India Seniority List of Superintendents of CGST & Central Excise, appointed to the grade during the period from 01.01.2007 to 31.12.2011 Click here
  • Draft Integrated All India Seniority List of Customs Appraisers for the period from 01.01.2012 to 31.12.2013 Click here
  • FAQs on GST applicability on ‘pre-packaged and labelled’ goods-reg. Click here
  • Vacancy Circular - Technical Officer Facilitation/Procedures (Grade A3) – in the Research and Policy Unit (Office of the Secretary General) at World Customs Organisation (WCO), Brussels. Click here   |   WCO Letter   |   Annex_1   |   Annex_2   |   Proforma
  • Online training on "Various issues relating to the illegal/unauthorized import of Jammers and other wireless products" on 28.07.2022 -reg. Click here
  • 16th Session of the Virtual Customs Orientation Academy (VCOA) will be held from 12 September 2022 to 16 December 2022-reg. Click here   |   WCO Letter   |   Annex_1   |   Annex_2   |   Proforma
  • Notice calling for suggestions, views, comments etc. from stakeholders on comprehensive changes in FORM GSTR-3B Click here
  • Final Zone Allocation of candidates selected through SSC CGLE 2019- reg Annexure-I   |   Annexure-II   |   Annexure-III   |   Annexure-IV   |   Covering Letter
  • Letter, Schedule, Syllabus, Instructions alongwith an Excel file (Requisition Form) regarding Departmental examination for Inspectors of Central Tax for Confirmation to be held from 02.08.2022 to 05.08.2022 issued by NACIN, ZC, Kanpur Letter and Details
  • Request for uploading instruction titled "Conduct of HC Litigation Monitoring Fortnight from 14.07.2022 to 27.07.2022 Click here
  • Warehousing of solar power generating units or items like solar panel, solar cell etc. for power plants with resulting goods ‘electricity’ - In-applicability of Manufacture and Other Operations in Warehouse (no.2) Regulations, 2019 under section 65 of the Customs Act, 1962 regarding Click here
  • Marks Declared: Marks of Deptt. Exam. for Inspectors of Central Tax held in 14.03.2022 to 16.03.2022 and 19.03.2022 declared. Nodal Officers (Exam) may download marks-sheet alongwith forwarding letter from their e-Mail ID.
  • Recruitment to the Post of Skipper on deputation-RegClick here
  • CBLR -2022 exam Declaration of date-regClick here
  • Online training on 'Budget Management: Estimation, Allocation & Expenditure' for Group 'A' officer of CBIC on 12.07.2022 from 10:30 AM to 01:15 PM -reg. Click here
  • Prospective Training for the month of July , 2022 Click here
  • Notification issued to notify the provisions of clause (c) of section 110 and section 111 of the Finance Act, 2022
  • Notification issued to exempt taxpayers having AATO upto Rs. 2 crores from the requirement of furnishing annual return for FY 2021-22
  • Notification issued to extend due date of furnishing FORM GST CMP-08 for the quarter ending June, 2022 till 31.07.2022
  • Notifications issued to extend the waiver of late fee for delay in filing FORM GSTR-4 for FY 2021-22 and to extend dates of specified compliance
  • Notifications issued to make amendments (First Amendment, 2022) to the CGST Rules, 2 017
  • Simplified regulatory framework for e-commerce exports of jewellery through Courier mode Circular and Notification
  • Notification issued on Notification for Departmental Examination for promotion of Tax Assistants to the Grade of Executive Assistants of Central Taxes & Customs to be held in the month of September, 2022. It also contains the Schedule, Syllabus and Instructions for Examination along with the format (in Annexure II) for requesting for Question Papers. Click here
  • Invitation for scholarship programme- Master Degree in Strategic Management and IPR at Aoyama Gakuin University (AGU) Tokyo Japan (2023-24)-reg. Click here | WCO Invitation   |   Annex-1   |   Annex-2   |   Annex-3   |   Proforma
  • Commendation Certificate on the occasion of 5th GST Day- regClick here
  • O.M. dated 24.06.2022 regarding Constitution of Internal FRACing Unit (IFU) - regarding Click here
  • Corrigendum dated 21.06.2022 regarding RFP No. NACIN/TRNG/232/2022-MCTP-O/o Pr. DG-NACIN-Faridabad dated 01.06.2022 to select a Partner Institute to conduct Phase-III and Phase-IV of Mid-Career Training Programme (MCTP) for IRS (C&IT) Officers Click here
  • Request for publishing notice inviting tender for hiring of office premisesat Bhopal for NACIN ZC, BhopalClick here
  • Independence Day Flag Ceremony at Red Fort on 15th August, 2022Click here
  • Posting of Joint Secretary/Commissioner in the Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs- reg. Click here
  • Combined Graduate Level Examination 2019- Final Verification of Options/Preferences– reg. | Annexure-A   |   Annexure-I   |   Annexure-II   |   Annexure-III   |   Annexure-IV   |   Covering Letter
  • Willingness of CBIC Inspectors for posting in Ad.IIIB on loan basis- reg. Click here
  • Procedure relating to sanction, post-audit and review of refund claims Click here
  • Requistion / Requirement of filling up posts on deputation in LPAI (MHA)-RegClick here
  • Notification issued on Notification for Departmental Examination for promotion of Ministerial Officers to the Grade of Inspectors of Central Taxes, Inspectors of Customs (Preventive Officers) & Inspectors of Customs (Examiners) to be held in the month of August, 2022. It also contains the Schedule, Syllabus and Instructions for Examination along with the format (in Annexure II) for requesting for Question Papers. Click here
  • Notice calling for feedback, inputs, comments etc. from all stakeholders on the draft circular and related notifications for facilitating e-commerce exports of Jewellery through courier mode, uploaded on 7th June 2022. Click here
  • Nomination calling for training on "Stress and Yoga: Curse and Cure" for Group A officers of CBIC on 21st June, 2022 at NACIN HQ, Faridabad -reg Click here
  • INVITATION FOR EXPRESSION OF INTEREST FOR SELECTION OF TRAINING PARTNERS/PARTNER INSTITUTE TO CONDUCT PHASE -III & PHASE -IV MID-CAREER TRAINING PROGRAMME (MCTP) FOR IRS (C & IT) OFFICERS Click here
  • CGLE 2019- Verification of Options/Preferences, and final chance for exercising options for left-out candidates | Annexure-A   |   Annexure-I   |   Annexure-II   |   Annexure-III   |   Annexure-IV   |   Document 5
  • Exemption in PET PST for recruitment to the post of Havaldar in CBIC Click here
  • -->
View All

BEFORE THE AUTHORTY FOR ADVANCE RULINGS
(CUSTOMS & CENTRAL EXCISE)
    NEW DELHI

 

P R E S E N T

 

Hon'ble Mr. Justice Syed Shah
Mohammed Quadri (Chairman)
Dr. K.N. Chaturvedi 
(Member)
Mr. Somnath Pal
(Member)

 

ADVANCE RULING No.AAR(CUS) /02 /2004

Application No.AAR/ 44/101 /2003

 

Name & Address of the applicant M/s.Sony India (P) Ltd.,
A-31,Mohan Co-operative
Industrial Estate, Mathura Road,
New Delhi-44.
Commissioner concerned Commissioner of Customs (ICD), 
 New Delhi

Commissioner of Customs (I & G)
New Dellhi

Present for the Department Shri P.K.Haldar,
Deputy Commissioner

Shri Sanjay Sharma &
Shri R.K.Jindal,Appraisers

Present for the Applicant Shri V.Laxmikumaran &

Shri R.Parthasarthy,Advocates

Shri Puneet Gupta,Sr.Engineer

R u l i n g
 (By Mr.Justice Syed Shah Mohammed Quadri)

 

               The applicant, M/s.Sony (India) Private Limited, filed this application under Section 28H of the Customs Act, 1962  (for short "the Act") seeking advance ruling of the authority on the following question of law:-

"Whether the concessional rate of customs duty of 5% would be applicable to the Panel AG Assembly in terms of Sl.No.110 of Notification No.25/99-Cus dated 28.2.99, as amended."

2. The applicant is a wholly owned subsidiary of Sony Corporation, Japan. It proposes to manufacture coloured picture tubes, cathode ray tubes, (for short CRT) based on patented Trinitron Technology.  It is stated that the components of CRT are as follows:-

a)      Funnel, which is a glass item having the shape of the color picture tube;

b)      Panel, which is also a glass shell item which is assembled in front of the funnel;

c)       FAG and Frame. It is a metal item with a special coating based on Trinitron Technology. The frame is  made of metal; and

d)      The Electron gun.

                        Out of these components, the applicant intends to procure (a)  in India and  import into India (b),  (c) and (d); (b) and (c) are proposed to be imported in blended form termed as Panel AG Assembly (for short PAGA).   The process of manufacturing CRT involves sealing the electron gun, (d), to the funnel (a) which will thereafter be fixed to PAGA.  The applicant claims that PAGA is covered by Sl.No.110 of the aforementioned Notification No.25/99-Cus dated 28.2.99 as such duty is leviable on it only at the concessional rate specified therein.  We are informed at the bar that the specified concessional rate of duty has since been reduced to "nil".  The claim of the applicant is opposed by the Commissioner of Customs (I & G).  It is stated by the Revenue that parts (b) and (c) are deliberately clubbed in the form of PAGA to circumvent the liability of payment of higher duty on part (b) which is a glass part.   The process of assemblying of two parts - a glass part and a metal part - is quite simple and they are assembled to lay claim erroneously that the composite assembly is dutiable only as a non glass part. PAGA it is stated, is essentially a glass part and so the attempt is to avail the concessional rate of duty indirectly as indeed the benefit of the notification is not applicable to the glass part directly. 

3.   Mr.V.Laxmikumaran, learned Advocate appearing for the applicant, contends that part (b) - a glass part -is liable to duty under Chapter 70 under heading 70.11 and part (c) is dutiable under heading 85.40 but in the form of assembly, PAGA  is liable to duty under heading 8540.91 as it ceases to be a glass part and therefore the concessional rate of duty under Sl.No.110 of the notification would apply.  He relied upon the judgement of the Supreme Court in Dunlop India Ltd. vs. Union of India and others [1976 (2) SCC 241] in support of his contention that the form of goods in which it is imported is a relevant factor for purposes of classification.  The learned Counsel has taken us through various notifications of the earlier years to impress upon us that there has been successive decrease in the rate of duty on the glass parts  and ultimately in the notification under consideration, list "C" is omitted  as the concessional rate of duty and the tariff rate are the same. From this, he would like us to infer that the benefit of concessional rate of duty under the notification will apply to PAGA.  He has also relied upon the Explanatory Notes to the Chapters 70, 84 and 85.  It is urged by the Revenue that the assembly is essentially a glass part and once the glass element is taken out there remains nothing in the assembly.  It is submitted that though the assembly-PAGA would be liable to the Customs duty under Chapter 85, the same is not covered under the notification so as to avail the benefit under Sl.No.110 of the notification.

4.  To appreciate the rival contentions of the parties, it would be apt to read the notification, insofar as it is relevant, here:

Notification No. 25/99-Cus., dated 28/2/1999

Concessional rate of duty on goods imported for the manufacture of excisable goods .- In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of section 25 of the Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962), the Central Government, being satisfied that it is necessary in the public interest so to do, hereby exempts the goods specified in column (3) of Table below, and falling under the Chapters of the First Schedule to the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975) specified in the corresponding entry in column (2) of the said Table, when imported into India for use in the manufacture of the finished goods specified in the corresponding entry in column (4) of the said Table, from so much of that portion of the duty of customs leviable thereon which is specified in the said First Schedule, as in excess of the amount calculated at the rate of, -

 

(a)       Nil in the case of the imported goods specified in List A; and

(b)       5% ad valorem in the case the imported goods specified in List B;

 

Provided that the importer follows the procedure set out in the Customs (Import of Goods at Concessional Rate of Duty for Manufacture of Excisable Goods) Rules, 1996.

 

TABLE

 

S.
No.
Chapter Description of imported
goods
 Description of finished
goods
1 2 3 4

 List A

               1 to 109          *               *                *

               110    85  Parts of  Cathode Ray Tubes Cathode Ray Tubes.  (other than Glass parts)

               113   85    Parts of Electron Guns Electron Guns,Television   picture tubes or Cathode  Ray Tubes.    

5.  A perusal of the portion of the notification, quoted above, shows that the Central Government, being satisfied that it is necessary in the public interest so to do, has exempted goods specified in column (3) of the Table falling under the Chapters of the First Schedule to the Customs Tariff Act,  (for short "the Tariff Act") specified in the corresponding entry in column (2) of the said Table when imported into India for use in the   manufacture of finished goods specified in the corresponding entry in column (4) of the said Table, from so much of that portion of the duty of customs leviable thereon which is specified in the said First Schedule, as is in excess of the amount calculated at the rate of  (a) "nil" in the case of the imported goods specified in list A and (b)  "5%" advalorem in the case of imported goods specified in list B.  Here we are concerned with the Sl.No.110 of list A of the notification which is in respect of "parts of Cathode Ray Tubes (other than glass parts)" specified in the Chapter 85 of the First Schedule to the Tariff Act, when imported into India provided they are used in the manufacture of Cathode Ray Tubes.   It is not disputed that the parts of Cathode Ray Tubes proposed to be imported, are meant for use in the manufacture of Cathode Ray Tubes in India.  The germane question, however, is whether PAGA would answer the description of "parts of Cathode Ray Tubes (other than glass parts)" in Sl. No 110.   It is a common ground that parts (a) and (b) are glass parts and part (c) is a metal part of CRT. Therefore, parts (a) and (b), the glass parts of CRT, are not covered by Sl.No.110 of the notification and are dutiable under Chapter 70 whereas part (c) a metal part of CRT, is dutiable under heading 8540. The question will then boil down to: What would be the position of PAGA -combination of parts (b) and (c) - a glass part with a metal part - in regard to applicability of concessional rate of duty under the Sl.No.110 of the notification.

6. Mr.Lakshmikumaran, argues that the history of the aforesaid notification, as is evident from notifications issued between 1995-96 and 1999-2000 would support that the concessional rate of duty applies to PAGA. To examine the contention we have carefully gone through the said notifications, tariff rates and the concessional rates.  It is noticed that when the effective rate of 30% was applicable to glass parts of CRT (excluding neck or reneck tubes), a concessional rate of 15% was granted to parts of CRT other than glass parts falling under Chapter 85; in 1996-97 and 1997-98 the glass parts of CRT were dutiable at the rate of 25% but the rate of duty on the non glass parts was 10%; from 1998-99 to 8/1/2004 the duty on glass parts was retained @ 25% but on the non glass parts it was reduced to 5%.  On 9-1-94 the concessional duty on the glass parts of CRT was reduced to 20% whereas on non glass parts it was reduced to "Nil".  In as much the effective rate of duty on the glass parts of CRT was the same in the Tariff Act as the concessional rate, list (C) was omitted from the last mentioned notification. From the above discussion, it is difficult to conclude that the history of the notification supports the contention that PAGA is dutiable at the concessional rate under the notification. 

 7. The next contention of the learned Counsel is that the HSN Explanatory Note for Heading 70.11 covers glass envelopes for electric lamps, CRT etc. (without fittings); like a glass envelope for ordinary 100 watts lamp with aluminum connection fitted which would be classified as a bulb under Heading 85.39 so on the same analogy the glass panel when integrated with AG Assembly and coated with RGB phosphor coating ceases to be a glass envelope simpliciter and becomes a part of CRT  classifiable under 8540.91.   The argument proceeds that once the classification of imported PAGA is under Chapter 85, the benefit of notification would automatically follow and that the expression  "other than glass parts"  used in Sl.No.110 is to distinguish it from the glass envelopes, which are also parts of CRT falling under Chapter 70 and is by way of abundant caution though not required strictly. 

8. The validity of the contention in regard to classification of PAGA need not be examined as the Revenue has conceded that PAGA is classifiable under Chapter 85.

9.   Even on the assumption that PAGA falls under chapter 85, it is not possible to hold that the benefit of the notification is automatic. To claim the benefit of the notification, the parts of CRT must be classifiable under chapter 85 but all the parts of CRT falling under that Chapter will not ipso-facto (by reason of that fact alone) enjoy the benefit of concessional rate of duty under the notification unless they answer the description of "parts of CRT (other than the glass parts)" in Sl.No.110 of the notification. 

10. The law in regard to interpretation of exemption notification is well settled.  An exemption has to be construed strictly but reasonably.  There is no scope of extending the meaning of the words and expressions used in the notification on the basis of analogy or on equitable consideration; there is also no scope for discerning the supposed intention and placing a purposeful construction to bring in goods within the meaning of the word or the expression employed in the notification. *

[ *  see       1.   Hico products Ltd. Vs.Collector of Central Excise, 1994 (71) ELT 339  (S.C)

                  2.   Bombay Chemical Pvt.Ltd.Vs.Collector of Central Excise, Bombay, 1995 (77) ELT 3 (S.C)

                  3.        Rajasthan Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd.Vs.Collector of Central Excise, Jaipur,1995 (77) ELT 474 (S.C)

                  4.        H.M.M.Ltd.Vs.Collector of Central Excise, New Delhi, 1996 (87) ELT 593 (S.C)

                  5.        Pappu Sweets and Biscuits and another Vs. Commissioner of Trade Tax, U.P., Lucknow, 1998 (7) SCC 228.]

   Against Sl. No.110, in the column of description of the goods, is noted "parts of CRT (other than glass parts)".    It has already been noted above that there are main 4 parts of CRT; Part (a) and (b) are glass parts and part (c) a non glass - a metal part and (d) electron gun.  We have no doubt that the notification deals with these and other parts of CRT (other than glass parts) and not with the combination of two or more parts.   While extending the benefit of concessional rate of duty to non glass parts, it excludes the glass parts.  Though it may be true that the glass parts and non glass parts when combined would equally form a part of CRT it cannot certainly be said to be a part of CRT other than a glass part. On plain reading of Sl.No.110, it is not possible to construe it as including combination of two or more parts of CRT.  In our view, no parallel can be drawn with part (d) electron gun, for electron gun by itself is a component of CRT and is a separate identifiable commercial goods as a part of CRT and clearly it falls under heading 8540.91.  There can be no dispute that the parts of a part are also parts of machine but it would be trite argument that the concession would then be applicable only to individual minor items like screw etc. as they are not known as parts of CRT.  We have already pointed out that the notification extends the benefit only to non glass parts and it is not available to an assembly of non glass parts and glass parts. If the contention of the applicant is accepted it would result in an anomalous situation giving scope to circumventing the higher rate of duty leviable on the glass parts by clubbing it with the metal part so as to make the assembly dutiable as applicable on metal parts.  Obviously such cannot be the interpretation of exemption notification. Having given anxious consideration, we are of the view that the benefit of exemption notification is available to such individual  parts as are generally accepted in common parlance and dealt with commercially in the market, and not to combination of two or more  parts like PAGA which are not bought and sold ordinarily in the market as parts of CRT by those dealing with parts of CRT.

For these reasons, we rule on the aforementioned question that the concessional rate of customs duty 5% (now nil) would not be applicable to panel AG Assembly in terms of  Sl. No. 110 of the notification dated 25/99 - Cus dated 28.2.99 as amended.

[Pronounced in this Authority in the presence of the parties on this day 13th April,2004]

 

Sd/
(Justice S.S.M.Quadri)

Chairman

Sd/
(Dr.K.N.Chaturvedi)

Member

Sd/
(Somnath Pal)
Member

 

Dated   13-04-2004      
F.No.AAR/44/101/2003